The Cost of a War, Part 2
What could we have done with the money that was wasted on the unnecessary Iraq War? Here are figures for Pierce County's share of this debacle, as well as national figures. Log in and comment on the numbers with your own suggestions of how we could have used the money.
| Pierce County | Washington State | United States | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taxpayer Dollars Spent | $1,200,000,000($1.2 billion) | $10,400,000,000 ($10.4 billion) | $490,720,000,000 ($490.72 billion) |
| Health Care for Adults | 182,967 | 1,558,283 | 73,526,025 |
| Residential Renewable Energy | 1,083,326 | 9,226,409 | 435,338,882 |
| Public Safety Officers (police, fire) | 23,353 | 198,889 | 9,384,378 |
| Music and Arts Teachers | 21,126 | 179,928 | 8,489,722 |
| University Level Scholarships | 216,772 | 1,846,191 | 87,110,676 |
| New Elementary Schools | 128 | 1,091 | 51,477 |
| Affordable Housing Units | 6,719 | 57,222 | 2,699,962 |
| Health Care for Children | 465,177 | 3,961,794 | 186,933,288 |
| Head Start for Children | 134,883 | 1,148,765 | 54,203,327 |
| Elementary School Teachers | 21,062 | 179,383 | 8,464,007 |
| Port Container Inspectors | 16,506 | 140,579 | 6,641,572 |
Sources:
Notes and Sources: Trade-Offs Page
Military Programs and Cost of the Iraq War:
For the following programs, we calculated each state's share of taxes paid into federal funds revenues (based on IRS data). This includes individual income taxes, corporate income taxes, excise, gift and estate taxes. Each state's share of taxes was then multiplied by the total amount of the given item. The Congressional District share is based on its population and median household income relative to the total state figure.
Amounts for military programs are for the proposed spending in the President's budget for fiscal year 2007 presented in February 2006.
Ballistic Missile Defense: According to the Center for Arms Control and Nuclear Proliferation, the total proposed spending for ballistic missile defense in the fiscal year 2007 budget would be $11 billion. This amount includes Space Based Infra-Red System - High.
Nuclear Weapons: According to the Budget of the United States Government, FY2007, spending on Department of Energy's Atomic Energy Defense Activities would be $17 billion.
Cost of Iraq War: The total amount allocated for war and occupation in Iraq is approximately $456 billion through fiscal year 2007. This amount will be updated with information on fiscal year 2008 when appropriate. For a discussion of the amount requested for FY2008, click here.
This number is based on an analysis of the legislation in which Congress has allocated money for war so far. Funding for the war has been initiated by the Bush Administration in supplementals:
FY2003 Supplemental: Operation Iraqi Freedom), made
in March 2003, was for $74.8 billion. Passed within a month of the
request, the final allocation amounted to $78.5 billion, at least $54.4
billion of which was for the war in Iraq.
FY2004 Supplemental: Iraq and Afghanistan Ongoing
Operations/Reconstruction, for $87 billion, was submitted in September
2003 and passed Congress in November 2003. The final allocation
amounted to $87.5 billion, of which $70.6 billion was for Iraq.
Budget Amendment: $25 Emergency Reserve Fund (Department of Defense -
Iraq Freedom Fund) was made in May 2004 and was passed by Congress as
part of the Department of Defense appropriations bill in July 2004.
Based on Iraq War spending, of the $25 billion appropriated, about
$21.5 billion was for the war in Iraq.
Estimate #1 - Emergency Supplemental (various agencies): Ongoing
Military Operations in the War on Terror; Reconstruction Activities in
Afghanistan; Tsunami Relief and Reconstruction; and Other Purposes -
2/14/05 was made in February 2005 and passed by Congress in April 2005.
The final allocation amounted to $82 billion, of which about $58
billion was for the Iraq War.
Department of Defense appropriations for fiscal year 2006 (i.e. war
funding not initiated by a supplemental request) included $50 billion
in a 'bridge fund' for war funding. Based on past Iraq War spending,
approximately $40 billion of that can be counted for the Iraq
War.
Estimate #3-FY 2006 Emergency Supplemental (various agencies): Ongoing
Military, Diplomatic, and Intelligence Operations in the Global War on
Terror; Stabilization and Counter-Insurgency Activities in Iraq and
Afghanistan; and Other Humanitarian Assistance-2/16/06 was for $72.4
billion, of which about $60 billion war for the Iraq War.
Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2007 appropriated another $70
billion in a bridge fund for the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, of which
approximately 85%, or $59.5 billion, is for the Iraq War. This
additional money will fund the conflict through March of 2007.
Additional 2007 and 2008 Proposals, Other Materials contains the
administration's supplemental request for an additional $100 billion in
war spending in FY 2007. NPP estimates that about $78.1 billion of the
money appropriated will be spent (has been spent) on the war in
Iraq.
Please note that the Department of Defense was also permitted by
legislation to transfer funds from other operations (peacetime,
Afghanistan, etc.) to the Iraq War, and so estimating war costs based
on Congressional legislation is not enough. An article offered by the
Strauss Military Reform Project of the Center for Defense Information
offers greater insight into the problems of truly knowing how much has
been spent on the Iraq War or other military operations. A
Congressional Research Service report also discusses the cost of the
wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Tax Cuts:
Each state's share is based on how much they received in federal aid to states for fiscal year 2004, the most recent year the data is available. The Congressional District breakdowns take the proportion of the state's population as its share of the state's federal aid to states.
$56.5 billion in tax cuts for the wealthiest 1%: According to the Tax Policy Center (Table T06-0034), the wealthiest 1% would receive one-fourth of the tax cuts this year (which would total around $220 billion).
Trade-Offs:
Elementary School Teachers, Music and Arts Teachers, Public Safety Officers, Police Officers, Firefighters, Nurses, and any other occupation: Each state's number is based on the average amount of annual pay an elementary school teacher receives, plus 25% for other expenses associated with employment such as benefits. These numbers are for 2005 from the Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates.
Head Start Places for Children: We calculated cost per child numbers for each state based on state numbers from the Administration of Children and Families' Head Start Bureau. These numbers are from 2005.
People or Children Receiving Health Care: The state numbers are based on the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Data Compendium. They represent the average Medicaid outlays per person or per child in each state for 1999 and 2000, and then are forecasted for 2005.
Elementary Schools: The cost of a new elementary school is based on the median amount spent on a 65,000 square foot elementary school in 2005, as reported by the School Planning and Management's 11th Annual Construction Report. A 65,000 square foot elementary school can accommodate roughly 500 students. Regional differences in cost are reflected in each states totals.
Scholarships for University Students: The number for each state is based on the cost of tuition and fees at that state's flagship university for the 2005-2006 academic year. Data on tuition and fees are available at the National Center for Education Statistics' College Opportunities On-Line (COOL).
Affordable Housing Units: The number for each state is based on Census 1990 and 2000 housing values. We have taken the average of the median and lower quartile values, and forecasted for 2005. This may be a fairly rough estimate of what is would cost to build affordable housing, but does constitute a good estimate of an inexpensive housing unit in each state.
Housing Vouchers: On average, each housing voucher is worth $6,665. While there is some variation between cities, we used the national average for each state because it represented the best guide for the value of a housing voucher. This amount is from the Congressional Budget Office.
Students receiving Pell Grants of $4050: The maximum Pell Grant award is currently set at $4050. We used that number for each of the states and for the United States as a whole. Information on the Federal Pell Grant Program can be found at the Office of Postsecondary Education at the US Department of Education.
Homes with Renewable Electricity : The average kWh per home was calculated with data from the Energy Information Administration on total residential electricity useage (by state) and number occupied households. The cost of wind energy is approximately 8 cents per kWh according to research done by Ryan Wiser and Edward Kahn at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. For our estimations, we've used 8 cents.